You are here

Jaluino Cuckoo meets Arduino

In last post, Jaluino Cuckoo has been briefly exposed, at least this is what I have i mind... The idea is to "parasite" the Arduino and put an small board with a Microchip PIC microcontroller, instead off Atmel chip. Just like brood parasite cuckoo birds squat in other species nests.

Now it's time to actually see how Jaluino Cuckoo could map Arduino pins. That is, we need to define which PIC's pins are mapped with Arduino's pins. This is an important step, as Atmel and Microchip chips are quite different, with different features, so a 100% mapping is hard to have, if not impossible. In the end, this is about making good compromises.

Overview of PIC18F25K22 features

In last post, PIC18F25K22 was chosen because it carries a lot of common features with Arduino, it has a lot of memory, runs fast, etc... Just to recall, Arduino provides:

  • USART serial
  • I²C amongst analog pins
  • SPI
  • 2 external interrupts
  • 6 PWM channels
  • 6 analog pins (or 4 if using I²C) and 1 voltage reference
  • some other digital I/O pins

Arduino features

 

 Now let's see how 18F25K22 features are distributed amongst its pins:

Cuckoo PIC18F25K22 features

There are several advantages using PIC18F25K22. It has 2 USART, 2 MSSP for SPI and I²C, independent ANSEL-like analog pins, some PWM pins can be multiplexed in fuse. This means there's a kind of flexibility while matching Arduino pins.

Tough pin mapping thoughts...

I started to match pin by features. Notations are A(p) for Arduino pin p, and J(p) for Jaluino pin p.

  • power: A(VCC) = J(Vdd) or A(AVCC) = J(Vdd), A(GND left) = J(Vss left), A(GND right)= J(Vss right). GND pin mappings can be inverted.
  • misc: A(RESET/PC6) = J(MCLR/RE3), A(XTAL1/PB6) = J(OSC1/RA7), A(XTAL2/PB7) = J(OSC2/RA6). XTAL pin mappings can be inverted
  • serial: TX1 pin also carries CCP3 PWM output. RX2/TX2 don't carry anything than USART module #2, so we'll match A(RX/PD0) = J(RX2/RB7) and A(TX/PD1) = J(TX2/RB6).
  • SPI: Arduino SPI is tricky as SS pin also carry PWM4 and MOSI also carry PWM5. This means, on Jaluino, we need to find pin with the same carried features. There's none... So this basically means we have to sacrifice 2 PWM channels in favor of SPI. Now which SPI module to choose ? SPI#2 pins on 18f25K22 also carry 3 external interrupts and 1 PWM outputs, and I consider external interrupts as important, so mapping will use SPI#2. Assuming MISO equivalent to SDO and MOSI equivalent to SDI, A(SCK/PB5) = J(SCK1/RC3), A(MISO/PB4) = J(SDO1/RC5), A(MOSI/PB3) = J(SDI1/RC4) and A(SS/PB2) = J(SS1/RA5). Note SPI#1 pins aren't closed together, this may be a problem while designing the PCB.
  • I²C: since we mapped SPI using MSSP#1, I²C will use MSSP#2. A(SCL/PC5) = J(SCL2/RB1), A(SDA/PC4) = J(SDA2/RB2)
  • Interrupts: this is a tough part, again compromise ahead... Consequence of SPI and I²C mapping: 18F25K22 INT1 and INT2 interrupt pins are shared with I²C pins. In Arduino, I²C pins don't carry interrupts. Again, we're loosing 1 interrupt ! The only remaining interrupt on Jaluino is INT0. Arduino INT1 also carries a PWM signal, same for INT0 on Jaluino. So let's match Jaluino INT0 with Arduino INT1: A(INT1/PD3) = J(INT0/RB0).
  • PWM: from 18F25K22 datasheet, I understand there are 2 standard CPP and 3 enhanced ECCP modules. I also understand this can produce up to 5 PWM channels. And I finally also understand some are multiplexed (CCP2* and CCP3*). We've already mapped A(PWM0) as it's also involved in interupts. We've also lost 2 PWM channels because of SPI mapping. On Arduino, MOSI/PB3 also carry PWM5 and we mapped it to RC4, which doesn't have PWM. Same for PWM4/SS. So, remaining PWM channels can go as: A(PWM1/PD5) = J(CCP1/RC2), A(PWM2/PD6) = J(CCP2*/RC1), A(PWM3/PB1) = J(CCP3*/RB5).
  • Digital I/O: there are 4 remaining digital I/O pin to map, why not A(PD4) = J(RC0), A(PD7) = J(RC7), A(PB0) = J(RC6). Note: two out of these can be used as another serial connection, an added feature coming with Cuckoo. Finally, we've lost an interrupt but we can map a PWM pin instead (not compatible, but a consolation. A(INT0/PD2) = J(CCP2*/RB3)
  • Analogs: finally, there are 4 remaining analog inputs. There are several possibilities since there are independent in 18F25K22 (can be configured independently from each other). Let's map A(AN3/PC3) = J(AN11/RB4), A(AN2/PC2) = J(AN0/RA0), A(AN1/PC1) = J(AN1/RA1), A(AN0/PC0) = J(AN0/RA0).
If you do the maths, you'll we have one remaining pin available from 18F25K22 (ATmega168 has VCC + AVCC while PIC18F25K22 has only Vcc). This pin is RA4, carrying PWM via CCP5. How can we use it ? We could map it a missing PWM channels, using a jumper onboard to activate this mapping.

Phew...

Let's sum up this in the following table:

.ArduinoJaluino CuckooComments
PowerVCCVddAVCC can also be mapped with Vdd

GNDleftVssleftGND left/right can be inverted

GNDrightVssright 
MiscRESET/PC6MCLR/RE3 

XTAL1/PB6OSC1/RA7XTAL can be inverted as needed
 XTAL2/PB7OSC2/RA6 
SerialRX/PD0RX2/RB7 
 TX/PD1TX2/RB6 
SPISCK/PB5SCK1/RC3 
 MISO/PB4SDO1/RC5 
 MOSI/PB3SDI1/RC4 
 SS/PB2SS1/RA5 
I²CSCL/PC5SCL2/RB1 
 SDA/PC4SDA2/RB2 
InterruptsINT1/PD3INT0/RB0this is also PWM0
PWMPWM1/PD5CCP1/RC2 
 PWM2/PD6CCP2*/RC1multiplexed with CCP2*/RB3 (PWM5)
 PWM3/PB1CCP3*/RB5 
Digital I/OPD4RC0these are the remaining ones...
 PD7RC7 
 PB0RC6 
 INT0/PD2CCP2*/RB3 
Analog inputsAN3/PC3AN11/RB4remaining ones...
 AN2/PC2AN0/RA0
 AN1/PC1AN1/RA1 
 AN0/PC0AN2/RA2 
 AREFVref+/RA3 
Extra

PWM5/MOSI/PB3

PWM4/SS/PB2

CCP5/RA4using jumper ?

 

This diagram may sum up this even better:

 

Arduino Cuckoo mapping

Limitations

Despite the great number of features brought by PIC18F25K22, we've lost a lot of them during this mapping:

 

  • 2 PWM outpus were sacrificed, PWM4 on DIGIT#10 and PWM5 onDIGIT#11. This pins can only be used as simple digital ones.
  • 1 interrupt was also discarded, INT0 on DIGIT#2.

 

Next steps ?

Schematic, PCB design, tests, failures, iterate...

 

Cheers
Sebastien Lelong